After a Privacy Breach: What Canada's Privacy Commissioner Asks For

After a Privacy Breach: What Canada's Privacy Commissioner Asks For

By Krikor Tengerian · Co-founder, SecuritAI Technologies Ltd. · November 2026 · 10 min read

The privacy breach is contained. The systems are back, the passwords are reset, and the customers have been told. Then someone on your team asks what the Privacy Commissioner is going to want from you, and nobody in the room can answer.

Most Canadian companies meet this question the same way, in the week after an incident, with the law open in one browser tab and a half finished timeline in another. You are not behind.

There is a public record that answers the question better than a guess. In 2026 the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, the OPC, published the outcomes of two investigations, together with the compliance letters behind them. This post reads those documents for one thing: what the regulator asked each company to show. For the law itself and its ten principles, start with our PIPEDA compliance page.

What the law asks first

Three duties sit in the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, known as PIPEDA. They apply before any investigation.

Report. Section 10.1 of PIPEDA says an organization shall report to the Commissioner any breach of security safeguards involving personal information under its control "if it is reasonable in the circumstances to believe that the breach creates a real risk of significant harm to an individual." The same section says the report is made as soon as feasible after the organization determines that the breach has occurred.

Notify. Section 10.1 also requires the organization to notify each individual whose personal information was involved, on the same test and also as soon as feasible. It names two factors for judging the risk: the sensitivity of the information, and the probability that it has been, is being or will be misused.

Record. Section 10.3 of the Act says an organization shall keep and maintain a record of every breach of security safeguards involving personal information under its control, and shall give the Commissioner access to a record, or a copy, on request. Section 6 of the Breach of Security Safeguards Regulations sets the period at 24 months after the day on which the organization determines that the breach has occurred.

Under all three sits the safeguards principle. Clause 4.7 of Schedule 1 of PIPEDA reads: "Personal information shall be protected by security safeguards appropriate to the sensitivity of the information." Clause 4.7.3 says the methods of protection should include physical measures, organizational measures and technological measures.

Size does not change any of this. The OPC's guide to mandatory breach reporting answers the question directly: large and small businesses are subject to the requirements to report and notify, and to keep records of all breaches of security safeguards.

Here is the part people get wrong

Most teams picture the regulator's answer to a breach as a penalty. They prepare for a fine.

The public record reads differently. The same OPC guide says the office does not prosecute under PIPEDA and does not issue fines. It explains that knowingly contravening the reporting, notification and record keeping requirements could lead to fines, and that the OPC can refer the matter to the Attorney General of Canada.

In the two outcomes below, the Commissioner asked for something else. A description of the safeguards. An outside firm's assessment of whether they work. A written answer to each recommendation. Dates for all of it.

In one word, evidence.

Loblaw: what the compliance letter asks for

According to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner, in its news release of October 26, 2026, Loblaw Companies Ltd. "has committed to take actions aimed at strengthening its security measures following a cyberattack that impacted approximately two million Canadians." The release says the breach occurred in February 2026. It says that in March 2026 Loblaw took steps to contain the breach with help from a third-party cybersecurity firm, posted a public notice about the incident, and notified the OPC.

The release says Loblaw signed a compliance letter with the OPC on October 21, 2026. The letter is published on the OPC's website, and it is specific. According to the letter, Loblaw will:

  • provide the Commissioner, by October 31, 2027, with a confidential security assessment and report prepared by an independent external security assessment firm that the OPC approves
  • inform the Commissioner in writing, by November 30, 2027, whether it has accepted each recommendation in that report, with reasons and alternative measures for any it has not accepted, and an implementation plan with dates for any that is not yet complete
  • confirm to the Commissioner, by November 16, 2026, that all affected individuals have been notified of the breach
  • describe, by January 31, 2027, the process used to determine who and what personal information was impacted, and its methodology for determining which individuals were subject to a real risk of significant harm
  • provide evidence that it has implemented these commitments within the committed timelines, with quarterly updates until all of them have been met

The letter states that it is not an admission of liability, fault or wrongdoing by Loblaw, and not a finding by the Commissioner that Loblaw contravened PIPEDA. And according to the OPC's release, the investigation will remain open until the Commissioner is satisfied that Loblaw has fulfilled all its commitments.

WestJet: from commitment to a closed file

According to the OPC's news release of July 14, 2026, WestJet "has committed to demonstrating that it has strengthened its security measures following a cyberattack that impacted more than five million current and former customers and employees." The release dates the breach to 2025.

The compliance letter, signed on July 8, 2026 and published by the OPC, set two dates. By August 7, 2026, WestJet would give the Commissioner a confidential summary report of a security assessment conducted by an independent external security assessment firm. The letter says the summary would include, at a minimum, a description of the safeguard enhancements, an assessment of their effectiveness, any remaining gaps, and recommended solutions. By September 7, 2026, WestJet would tell the Commissioner whether it had accepted each recommendation, and how it would address each one. This letter carries the same statement as the first: it is not an admission of liability or wrongdoing, and not a finding that PIPEDA was contravened.

Then came the result. In a news release of October 14, 2026, the OPC said the Commissioner announced that WestJet "has met the commitments that it made to his Office." The release says that in the letter the company confirmed it had reinforced multi-factor authentication requirements, strengthened identity and access controls, and improved its overall security awareness. Its last line on the matter reads: "Now that the company has demonstrated to the OPC's satisfaction that it has met all of its commitments, Commissioner Dufresne has closed the investigation."

The verb in that sentence is demonstrated.

What the two letters have in common

The same requests appear in both letters.

  • The safeguards, in writing. Each letter records the measures the company put in place after the breach, and each outside report has to include a description of the safeguard enhancements.
  • An outside assessment. The Loblaw letter says the firm is to be approved by the OPC, and a footnote in the WestJet letter says its firm was approved by the OPC.
  • An answer to every recommendation. Accepted or not, with reasons, alternative measures, and dates for anything unfinished.
  • Verification. Both letters say the Commissioner may request information and documents to verify that the organization is fulfilling its commitments.
  • Notification. Both letters say the investigation looked at two things: the adequacy of the security safeguards in place at the time of the breach, and the adequacy of the notifications to affected individuals.

None of these is a new security control. Each one is proof that a control exists and works.

The evidence problem for a smaller company

You may never sign a compliance letter. The three duties in the Act still apply to you, and the record keeping duty applies to every breach, including the ones you decide not to report.

The OPC's breach reporting guide says what it expects a breach record to hold as a starting point: the date or estimated date of the breach, a general description of the circumstances, the nature of the information involved, and whether the breach was reported to the Commissioner and individuals were notified. Where a company decided not to report, the guide says the record could include a brief explanation of why it determined there was not a real risk of significant harm.

Here is the pattern our team sees. Most companies have safeguards. Far fewer can show them. The setting is on, but nobody can say when it was last checked. The training happened, but there is no list of who attended. A small incident was handled well last spring, and it was never written down.

A short file to build before you need it:

  • A breach record, with one entry for every incident and the reasoning behind each decision to report or not report. Keep each entry for at least the 24 months the Regulations require.
  • A dated description of your safeguards, sorted the way clause 4.7.3 sorts them: physical, organizational and technological.
  • For each safeguard, one piece of proof that it is in place today, with a date on it.
  • The result of your last outside assessment or test, if you have had one, and what you did about each recommendation.
  • A notification template that already has the fields section 3 of the Regulations requires, so the first draft does not start from a blank page.

Our PIPEDA compliance checklist works through the ten principles and the breach record one line at a time, with the document you would hand over beside each.

Where SecuritComply fits

SecuritComply maps PIPEDA's 10 fair information principles to controls, each tied to its evidence. It has a breach log that holds the risk of harm assessment for each entry. The platform keeps that evidence in one place, so it is ready when a customer, an insurer or a regulator asks. Your compliance data stays in Canada.

Built to save your team time and money: every control is tied to its evidence, so internal reviews can run shorter and your evidence is in order when a customer, insurer or regulator asks.

To see how the platform handles the federal privacy law, and to start free, go to our PIPEDA compliance page. If you would rather start on paper, the free readiness checklists, including the Cyber Insurance Readiness Checklist and the Security Questionnaire Answer Key, are on our resources page.

Frequently asked questions

What is a privacy breach?

The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada says a privacy breach occurs when there is a loss, unauthorized access to, use or disclosure of personal information. PIPEDA uses the term breach of security safeguards, which it defines as the loss of, unauthorized access to or unauthorized disclosure of personal information resulting from a breach of an organization's security safeguards, or from a failure to establish those safeguards.

When do I have to report a privacy breach to the Privacy Commissioner?

Section 10.1 of PIPEDA requires a report when it is reasonable in the circumstances to believe that the breach creates a real risk of significant harm to an individual. The report is made as soon as feasible after the organization determines that the breach has occurred, and affected individuals must be notified on the same test.

How long do I have to keep breach records?

For 24 months. Section 6 of the Breach of Security Safeguards Regulations says an organization must maintain a record of every breach of security safeguards for 24 months after the day on which it determines that the breach has occurred. Section 10.3 of PIPEDA says the Commissioner can ask for access to a record or a copy.

Does the Privacy Commissioner issue fines after a breach?

The OPC's breach reporting guide says the office does not prosecute under PIPEDA and does not issue fines. It says knowingly contravening the reporting, notification and record keeping requirements could lead to fines, and that the OPC can refer the matter to the Attorney General of Canada.

What is a compliance letter?

It is a set of written commitments a company makes to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner during an investigation. In its October 26, 2026 news release, the OPC describes voluntary compliance letters as a way to resolve privacy issues more efficiently with companies that are motivated to improve their practices. Both letters discussed here say the investigation will be discontinued once the Commissioner is satisfied that the commitments have been fulfilled.

References

Ready to get compliant?

SecuritComply makes it simple: 17 frameworks and Canadian data residency.

Start Free →